Öcalan's attorney: Turkey is misleading, responsibility lies with the EC

  • actual
  • 11:12 16 November 2021
  • |
img
İSTANBUL - Stating that the "action plan" submitted to the EC Committee of Ministers is far from the violation decision made for Öcalan, lawyer Rezan Sarıca said, "Turkey's membership to the EC may be a matter of discussion if it is determined that it does not act in accordance with the decision."
 
The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has ruled that the aggravated life sentence for PKK Leader Abdullah Öcalan, who has been held in İmralı Type F High Security Closed Prison since 15 August 1999, violates the 3rd paragraph of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), which prohibits torture and ill-treatment. Following this decision on March 18, 2014, a violation decision was made for the detainees Hayati Kaytan, Emin Gurban and Civan Boltan on the same issue. Despite the fact that 7 years have passed since the violation decision was made for Öcalan and other prisoners, no action has been taken which mobilized legal and human rights organizations.
 
The Association of Lawyers for Freedom (ÖHD), Society and Legal Studies Foundation (TOHAV), Human Rights Association (İHD) and Human Rights Foundation of Turkey (TİHV) which are members of the Committee of Ministers of Council of Europe (AK BK) which oversees and implements the decisions made by the ECtHR applied to the Committe on July 26. The committee then put the issue on its agenda for the first time and decided to discuss the decision at the meeting to be held between November 30 and December 2.
 
'SPECIAL LAW' FOR IMRALI
 
Turkey made two separate notifications after the Committee brought the issue to the agenda. Turkey claimed in its notifications that there has been no violation in Imrali since 2009. Turkey ignored the findings and suggestions regarding “securing the right to hope” and “legal amendments on the regime of the execution of aggravated life sentence”. Since 2009, Öcalan and other prisoners have been prevented from meeting with their families and lawyers for various reasons.
 
In the notification it presented to the Committee on October 7 with the title "Action Plan", Turkey stated that Öcalan and other prisoners do not have the right to "conditional release" and accepted the "private law" was practiced in Imrali. 
 
Rezan Sarıca, one of the lawyers with the Asrın Law Office, made evaluations to the Mezopotamya Agency (MA) regarding Turkey's notifications and possible decisions to be made by the Committee.
 
TURKEY INSISTS THERE ARE NO VIOLATIONS OF RIGHTS IN IMRALI
 
Stating that Turkey has taken an approach far from the essence of the issue with its notifications, Sarıca spoke about Turkey's insistance that there are no violations of rights in İmralı. Sarıca said: "Turkey's notifications in this direction are not new. It claimed that the decision was fulfilled in its notifications in 2016. Therefore we should once again focus on the ECtHR decision. The main issue is that the life sentence will actually be for life which means they can't get out of the prison unless they are dead. ECtHR says this is torture. It is pointless that Turkey says there is no violation in İmralı."
 
MISLEADING STATEMENTS
 
Stating that Turkey's claims that there are no violations in İmralı is about the visitation rights, Sarıca said: "Turkey's response was about the isolation. However the Committee is more interested in 'life imprisonment', not the isolation part.It monitors this issue in Turkey's legislation. Will it be a development in line with the ECtHR's decision or not? This is what they are observing. Therefore, it will evaluate the notifications submitted by both NGOs and Turkey and monitor whether there are developments in line with the decision. 
 
TURKEY'S PURPOSE
 
Sarıca noted that the persistance of Turkey ignoring the demands made by NGOs, means it will not comply with the decision. Sarıca said: " The 'action plan' presented by Turkey does not bear any indication of the process followed by the Committee. It is not realistic and not applicable. In short, "There is an approach that evades it. Turkey is trying to divert the attention of the Committee with this. It expects the Committee to move away from the decision and display an unlawful approach."
 
RESPONSIBILITY LIES WITH THE COMMITTEE
 
Stating that their main demand from Turkey is to bring the existing law to a level compatible with the ECtHR and human rights, Sarıca emphasized that Turkey should also present a realistic and applicable action plan to the monitoring process. Sarıca said, "The action plan and the answers it has presented so far are not in line with this. We demand that it be made in accordance with the ECHR decision. However, Turkey insists that it will not fix it. We see that it will act against the law, will not recognize the ECHR decision, and will try to mislead the monitoring process of the Committee. If it will not fulfill its obligations, the duty and responsibility in this regard lies with the Committee. And in case the Committee determines that Turkey did not comply with the decision, Turkey's relations with the Committee of Ministers of Council of Europe will be discussed. Turkey has to act in accordance because it is a member. Turkey's membership will be at risk if Turkey insists on not complying with the decision. Other sanctions may also be imposed."
 
 
MA / Gökhan Altay - Mehmet Aslan

View More Articles

19/05/2025
16:40 100 families return to Shengal
16:28 Tent protest against embargo enters its 5th day
16:12 Ocak and Karakoç commemorated during Week of the Disappeared
15:51 PUK and KDP to participate in Iraqi elections with separate lists
14:15 DEM Party's meeting programme with political parties clarified
13:49 DEM Party and DEVA meeting ends
13:39 Participants at commemoration of Kaytan and Altun: Time to build social peace
13:15 Place to discuss the process is Parliament says Parliamen speaker Kurtulmuş
12:45 '2 thousand 728 young lost their lives in workplace homicides in 12 years'
12:11 'They were fighters for freedom and truth'
11:29 'Internationalist women’s movement must be established'
10:37 The struggle not over, method has changed says Sebahat Tuncel
09:51 Some houses built of memory and resistance
18/05/2025
20:48 Message from Abdullah Öcalan: A new contract is needed
20:39 Bahçeli proposes establishment of a 100 members commission
19:55 Thousands commemorate Kaytan and Altun at Şêx Seîd Square
18:15 DEM Party İmralı delegation return from İmralı
14:18 Peace Mothers in Amed for the commemoration: Öcalan must be free
13:26 They set out for the Kaytan and Altun commemoration
13:11 Participants in commemoration in Dêrsim: No unilateral peace
12:53 76-year-old ill prisoner's health deteriorating
12:42 DEM Party delegation goes to İmralı Island
12:22 80 ill prisoners in prisons in Mediterranean Region
11:14 They inherited struggle of Kaytan and Altun
10:30 Full support to process in Cizîr: The state must take the necessary steps
09:58 New page opened, accumulated problems must be eliminated says lawyer of Öcalan
17/05/2025
11:23 'PKK has done its part, the next stage will be the steps of the state'
11:15 EP Rapporteur Amor: PKK's decision excellent news, opportunity must not be wasted
16/05/2025
15:53 Abdullah Öcalan's photograph 42 years ago published
15:12 Kaytan and Altun commemorated in Wan: They never bowed down
13:27 Sabri Ok: Believe in yourself and Leader Apo
Besta Botan: Struggle based on democratic politics begins
13:18 ‘Legal steps must be taken for a democratic solution’
12:10 'Process' visits to 5 thousand families
11:32 Families applies to go to İmralı
11:25 Local associations: We must take part in the process
15/05/2025
16:59 Mehmet Şirin Tekmenüray releases after 32 years
16:54 PKK's founding cadres Altun and Kaytan commemorated in many cities
16:43 Journalist Furkan Karabay arrests
16:29 Makhmur citizens marching against embargo launch tent action
16:01 Commemoration of Kaytan and Altun: They built a great tradition
14:02 Wan citizens: Now it's the government's turn
12:18 ‘The state has serious responsibilities for a solution’
11:25 Makhmur Camp has been blockaded for a month
10:32 Witness of the PKK’s founding congress: Peace will come with the last congress
09:58 Fatma Özbay releases
09:43 Peace Group Member Tunç: Kurdish reality must be acknowledged for success of process
09:08 Journalist Karabay detained
08:29 Makhmur delegation detained
14/05/2025
16:45 Justice Minister responds to request for Öcalan to meet with journalists and politicans
16:20 NADA to hold its first congress in Sulaymaniyah