Attorney Şakar: Committee of Ministers cannot act as if there is no ECtHR decision

  • actual
  • 15:28 23 September 2022
  • |
img
DİYARBAKIR - Stating that the condemnations to the situation of not hearing from PKK Leader Abdullah Öcalan exceeded the borders of the country, Lawyer Mahmut Şakar said: “The Committee of Ministers cannot act as if there is no ECtHR decision because the ECtHR decision is about the area that the Turkish state calls an exception."
 
There has been no news for 18 months from PKK Leader Abdullah Öcalan and prisoners Hamili Yıldırım, Veysi Aktaş and Ömer Hayri Konar, who are being held under heavy isolation conditions in İmralı Type F High Security Prison. In order to break the isolation in question, hundreds of lawyers from all over the world applied to the Ministry of Justice to meet with Abdullah Öcalan and other prisoners. 350 lawyers in 22 countries sent letters to the Ministry of Justice, European Bar Association, Turkish Bar Association and international human rights organisations on September 14. Later, 756 lawyers from Morocco, Palestine, Federated Kurdistan Region, Northern and Eastern Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Egypt, Syria and Jordan made a separate application to the ministry on September 19 under the leadership of the Arab Legal Initiative for the Freedom of Abdullah Öcalan. In the applications, it was emphasized that the deepened isolation violated the international conventions. Mahmut Şakar, the attorney of PKK Leader Abdullah Öcalan, one of the signatory lawyers, answered our questions about the applications and roadmaps for the upcoming period.
 
HUNDREDS OF LAWYERS AROUND THE WORLD TAKE ACTION FOR ÖCALAN
 
Stating that it is important that hundreds of lawyers around the world take action for PKK leader Abdullah Öcalan and 3 prisoners, attorney Mahmut Şakar said:"
The condemnations created by the absence of news for 18 months gradually crossed the borders of the country and caused a large part of it to condemn. The international condemnation against the isolation also reveals how wide a segment of the population understands both the isolation and the political mission that Mr. Öcalan represents. The fact that no news has been received from Mr. Öcalan and his friends since March 25, 2021 is actually an important issue not only for his family and lawyers, but also for the entire society and the international community. It has also begun to be better understood that the solution is to break the isolation and pave the way for a peaceful and resolving politics. From this point of view, I think that more serious and effective events will develop in the international arena."
 
THE COMMITTEE OF MINISTERS CANNOT ACT AS IF THERE IS NO ECtHR DECISION
 
Emphasizing that the Committee of Ministers did not take a sanction decision for Turkey's exemption from Öcalan's right to hope, Şakar said: "The ECtHR gave its decision in 2014;however, the Committee of Ministers put this issue on its agenda only on the date I mentioned, namely in 2021. We need to express that this delayed agenda is already an unserious behavior. The Committee of Ministers cannot act as if there is no ECtHR decision and cannot engage in an 'exemption' attitude anyway because the ECtHR decision is already related to the area that the Turkish state calls an exception. The main question is how seriously the Committee of Ministers will take the Turkish state to resolve this issue, whether it will allow this issue to extend over a period of time, and whether it will follow up on this issue until a fair solution is developed. You have to be careful in these matters. In particular, the Kurdish society, civil society, democratic sections and international legal circles need to monitor the developing process before the Committee of Ministers and put constant pressure on the Committee. I think that the assurance of the process is these segments.
 
MA / Eylem Akdağ
 

View More Articles

16/11/2025
16:51 Tülay Hatimoğulları: Hands off Dêrsim
16:24 Demirtaş: We will definitely build a free and just future together
15:17 Protesters march ahead of anti-exploitation rally
14:25 ‘The Commission must go to Imrali, the doors must be fully opened’
14:14 Despite disability report, prisoner repeatedly arrested and released
13:55 Relative of prisoner: The state’s mask falls inside prisons
10:54 AKP’s 23-year record: At least 8 thousand 33 women killed
13/11/2025
16:06 Date set for Parliamentary Commission meeting
15:08 Government should clarify its stance on possible talks with Ocalan says DEM Party Spokesperson
13:23 What awaits Syria after Shara’s U.S. visit
11:07 Two DNA samples found on Rojin’s body confirmed not to be contaminants
10:27 Rojhilat lawyer advocates for Kurdish language in law
09:24 TJA members: Women will lead the peace process
08:24 Unofficial preliminary results of Iraq election announced
12/11/2025
13:08 What the Iraqi election results reveal
12:50 Third obstacle to release of prisoner who refused to accept imposed remorse
12:01 ‘Transition needed from negative peace to positive peace process’
11:23 Turkey not withdrawing from Syria, targets new bases
10:15 Denis O’Hearn: Ocalan’s new analysis is amazing, even unprecedented in world history
11/11/2025
16:53 Sincan Prison doctor ‘on leave’: Prisoners denied medical treatment
16:39 İHD sends letters to Parliament parties for release of ill prisoner Hatice Onaran
16:36 Istanbul Chief Prosecutor files request to Supreme Court to close down CHP
16:26 Death toll rises to three in Pasur bridge collapse
14:41 Parliament Speaker to meet group deputy chairs
14:34 In Tekirdağ, Kurdish language under threat from state institutions
12:58 Facing deaths is essential for lasting peace says Researcher Şilan Bingöl
10/11/2025
16:32 CPT: Turkey increasing number of military bases
15:17 11th Judicial Package targets women’s rights
09:54 Despite process, agent imposition continues
09/11/2025
16:54 TJA kicks off 25 November
15:45 Writer and politician İshak Tepe passes away
15:30 Minister of Justice on Demirtaş: The decision is before the court
14:09 Dersim Odjak’s women: Everyone must take responsibility for peace
12:08 Lost two children in conflict: Only thing that can heal my pain is peace
10:27 Umut Bookstore bombing marks 20 years: state must face its crimes
07/11/2025
13:13 Amed Bar Association Vice Chair: The durability of the process depends on legal safeguards
11:48 28 suspicious deaths of women in Wan over two years
10:53 ‘Women’s Cities’ to be announced
09:59 'The state must respond to the process with constitutional reforms'
06/11/2025
16:42 HRW briefing on the parliamentary commission
14:52 Prisoner's family not informed about his heart attack
13:33 Sedat Akgok releases after 31 years in prison
13:20 DEM Party Central Executive Committee convened
12:21 Suweyda countryside bombed
12:16 We must strive for the process to be successful says Prof. Gunerhan
11:04 Taking steps will pave the way for integration says Tiryaki
10:45 Six journalists called to testify as part of “Imamoğlu” investigation
05/11/2025
15:58 Journalist Aykol enters fourth stage of treatment
14:56 Parliament Speaker to meet party coordinators ahead of commmission session
14:50 Reacted to ID check, beaten and handcuffed