Solution is not abolishing Lausanne, but establishing a democratic constitution says Historian Ulugana

img
ISTANBUL – Commenting on the ongoing debates about the Treaty of Lausanne, historian Sedat Ulugana said, “The resolution of the Kurdish issue does not lie in abolishing Lausanne. The solution is the establishment of a democratic and pluralist constitution.”
 
Following Kurdish Leader Abdullah Öcalan’s “Call for Peace and Democratic Society,” the PKK held its 12th Congress and decided to dissolve itself. In its statement, the PKK said, “Our party, the PKK, emerged as a Kurdish freedom movement in opposition to the denial and annihilation policies rooted in the Treaty of Lausanne and the 1924 Constitution”
 
Some nationalist and Kemalist circles, known for their consistent opposition to a peaceful and democratic solution to the Kurdish issue, targeted this discourse. Evaluating the historical context of Lausanne and its role in the unresolved Kurdish issue, historian Sedat Ulugana explained that Kemalists interpret Lausanne as “the title deed of Turkey”.
 
In contrast, neo-Otoomanists argue that “the treaty restricted Turkey.” Ulugana highlighted two crucial points for Turkey in Lausanne: “First, the abolition of capitulations; second, ensuring no concessions were made on borders, particularly aiming to include Mosul and Aleppo withing Turkey’s borders.”
 
Ulugana emphasized that a consensus favourable to Turkey had been formed prior to the treaty and said: “Lausanne was not a negotiation process that started from scratch. Kurds were not even mentioned during the talks. The Turkish side argued, ‘We are here on behalf of both Turks and Kurds.’ This is stated directly by Ismet Pasha. Within this international consensus, Kurds were left without status. That is the treaty’s historical significance.”
 
TWO MAIN ISSUES FOR TURKEY IN LAUSANNE
 
Ulugana elaborated, “The first issue was the abolition of capitulations, heavily negotiated with the French, who had significant economic interests in the Ottoman infrastructure. The second issue was border definitions, particularly with Syria, for which Turkey sought guarantees from France.”
 
THE CURZON–INONU DEBATE
 
Ulugana recalled the negotiations between Ismet Inonu and Lord Curzon, the British representative chairing the conference. “Turkey claimed Mosul belonged to them due to a Kurdish and Turkmen majority. Inonu argued Kurds were a Turanic people, while Curzon insisted they were of Iranian origin. Inonu proposed a referendum on the matter, to which Curzon responded that Kurds ‘would not understand what a ballot box is.’ Inonu retorted, ‘You cannot insult my Kurdish brothers this way.’” Ulugana noted, “This exemplified the duplicitous nature of the talks. Ultimately, Mosul was left to Britain, solidifying the partition of Kurdistan.”
 
KURDISH REACTION TO LAUSANNE
 
According to Ulugana, the main Kurdish grievance was the partitioning of Kurdistan. “Kurdish MPs in the Assembly, such as Hasan Hayri Bey and Yusuf Ziya Bey, harshly criticized Ismet Pasha, calling it betrayal,” he said. These MPs had believed in a joint Turkish-Kurdish state. However, with the 1924 Constitution and the dissolution of the first parliament, “the republic began to be built solely on Turkish identity.” The exclusion of Kurdish MPs and ensuing repression led to covert organization among Kurdish officers, culminating in failed military uprisings such as those linked to the Azadi Committee.
 
'THE ISSUE IS NOT LAUSANNE, BUT A DEMOCRATIC CONSTITUTION'
 
Ulugana stressed that Lausanne itself is not what restricts Kurds: “What restricts the Kurds is the internal structure of the state. First, the dissolution of the parliament. Second, the undemocratic nature of the 1924 Constitution,” he continued, “The expectation that the Turkish delegation would defend Kurdish rights in Lausanne was misguided. We’re still seeing the same process today. Will foreign powers like the U.S. or Israel defend Kurdish rights, or will the Turkish state, founded jointly with the Kurds, write a new democratic constitution to enshrine genuine brotherhood?”
 
He concluded: “The resolution of the Kurdish issue is not the annulment of the Treaty of Lausanne. It lies in the formation of a democratic, pluralist constitution.”
 
MA / Melik Celik

View More Articles

21/06/2025
11:29 Amed Bar Association Chair: The process is about to take flesh and bones
11:25 76 per cent disabled prisoner's life in danger
20/06/2025
16:31 Rehan Bayık laid to rest
15:14 Families apply to İmralı Directorate
14:54 Grave of YJA Star member Revan Zana Barıştıran vandalised
14:12 Turkey shelled villages in Dohuk
13:52 ‘Removal Centers must be closed, refugee rights should not be bargained’
13:23 Report from ÖHD on Antalya Prisons: Right to medical treatment blocked
11:48 Successive sexual offence against children: Perpetrator released
10:26 Amed citizens: If process prolonged, Israeli-Iranian conflict will spread here
09:39 Kurdish Women's Platform Conference to be held in Amed
09:37 ‘The antidote to the monoethnic nation-state in the Middle East is the democratic nation’
09:18 Call for sensitivity from a mother whose son is on hunger strike
09:17 11 days solitary confinement penalty to ill prisoner in Bolu
09:15 She lost her husband and son: They must stop the war and take steps for peace
09:14 Peace Mothers: The state must take urgent action
19/06/2025
16:48 Release demand for ill prisoner Giyasettin Sevmiş
16:40 Peace Mother Latife Dag passed away
16:37 Mother of Cemil Bayık passed away
15:27 Collective Bargaining Agreement demands by union
14:38 Our draft for the commission is ready says Ayşegül Doğan
14:12 Release of prisoner Çetin Arkaş postponed for the 7th time
13:39 Father of Güney Doğan, killed in the Ankara Train Station Massacre: Their dream was peace
12:21 DEM Party delegation goes to Silivri for 'process' talks with prisoners
11:39 PJAK Director Mûînî: Kurdish forces must act jointly
11:25 EMEP Chair Aslan: A unified struggle is necessary
10:44 Berwarî: If Iran doesn’t democratize, it will lose the next century
10:15 Rojda Yıldız from Jineology: Matrilineal values must be revived
09:07 Marija Arsenkova: Öcalan and the PKK did the right thing, now it's Turkey's turn
18/06/2025
15:16 KJAR: Without presence of women, one cannot speak of a free future for Iran
13:36 Wife of ill prisoner Çam: Decision is attempted murder
13:22 Son of Eyşe Şan: My mother is now entrusted to Kurdish people
11:48 Writer Aktaş: There is need for a new understanding of the region as stated by Öcalan
10:25 ‘Call of Öcalan is the foundation of the Yazidi renaissance’
09:21 Mithat Sancar becomes new member of İmralı Delegation
09:20 ‘Öcalan's approach holds potential to end century bloodshed in Middle East’
08:54 Israel-Iran continue mutual attacks
17/06/2025
17:26 Sema Yüce commemorated
17:18 Kurdistan bar association chairs meets with DEM Party
17:09 Deniz Poyraz commemorated
16:55 What discussed in İmralı: DEM Party must realise its potential
16:29 PJAK: We will not leave our people defenseless
09:53 4 journalists arrested
09:47 Padel: Model of democratic confederalism is something the world absolutely needs to learn from
09:25 Snapshot of attack on Kurdish memory: Garzan Cemetery
09:14 Cultural heritage neglected: Kepenek Church being used as a barn
16/06/2025
16:29 Erdogan to Pezeshkian: Return to negotiations
14:43 Release of 32 year prisoner postponed for 8th time
13:57 Ill prisoner not referred to ATK despite prosecutor's decision
13:44 Prisoner's release postponed for 6 months