The Supreme Court applied against the acquittal of the 'good boys'.

  • actual
  • 15:56 27 September 2022
  • |
img
VAN - An appeal was made to the Court of Cassation against the acquittal of the local court against the non-commissioned officers Ali Kaya and Özcan İldeniz and the confessor Veysel Ateş, who were caught red-handed while bombing the Umut Bookstore.
 
The verdict of acquittal in the lawsuit, filed for "killing people", "establishing an organisation" and "attempting to kill people" about Ali Kaya and Özcan İldeniz, and confessor Veysel Ateş, who were caught red-handed, who was caught red-handed by bombing the Umut Bookstore in the Şemdinli district of Hakkari, causing the death of a person, and whom the then Chief of Staff Yaşar Büyükanıt said that he knows them, they are good boys, was appealed to the Court of Cassation by the Van Bar Association.
Announcing its reasoned decision on August 26, 9 months after the verdict of the case, the Van 1st High Criminal Court argued that it would not be reasonable, logical and lawful for public personnel and public institutions to engage in such an action.
 
ACQUITTAL JUSTIFICATION OF THE COURT
 
In the reasoned decision, which claimed that there was no conviction that the bombs dropped on the day of the incident were carried out by the defendants, it was claimed that the sketch, gun and other crime tools in the vehicle were put by the organisation. In the decision, the following statements were included: “As it can be seen from the detection minutes, there are two notebooks with names and phone numbers in the bag, and two hand grenades in the zippered bag in the trunk; The German-made handgun used by the organisation, which is not registered in the TAF inventory, was not registered in the TAF inventory, because the persons close to the organisation established de facto dominance over the vehicle during this period, the organisation's members were ordered to burn the vehicle, but the judicial authorities were able to make a safe discovery around 21.10 hours by the judicial authorities. The defense of the defendants, who are in charge of the fight against terrorism, that the bombs were subsequently placed in the trunk of the vehicle should be respected.”
 
EVIDENCE WASN'T FOUND!
 
Despite the death lists, bombs, sketches and many other evidences found in the trunk of the vehicle by the people of Şemdin, the decision alleged that there is no evidence that the material and moral elements of the crimes committed against the accused were formed and used the words of “The characterization of the criminal suspects, who took part in the fight against the separatist terrorist organisation, which carried out acts aimed at disrupting the unity of the country, as having committed the same crime as the crimes committed by this organisation would mean a result that lacks legal value based on assumptions, and that the public personnel and public institutions in charge of the fight against terrorism would not act in such a way. It has been concluded that it would not be in accordance with reason, logic and law to engage in action."
 
WHY WAS IT BOMBED IF THERE IS NO PERSONAL ENEMY?
 
In the decision, which is defended that the defendants went to Şemdinli to collect information, the following was noted: “The defendants, who are in charge of the fight against terrorism, will need to carry out the acts of killing, attempting to kill and injuring the victims and participants in the district of Şemdinli, where they were on the day of the incident, for the purpose of gathering intelligence. Considering that they also did not have personal enmities, it was concluded that apart from the allegations of Seferi Yılmaz, who did not give rise to a conviction according to the evidence in the file, the defendants were acquitted."
 
‘BELIEF IN JUSTICE IS DESTROYED'
 
Following the reasoned decision, Hamza Çiftçi, a lawyer on behalf of the Van Bar Association, appealed to the Court of Cassation against the acquittal decision. In the application, it was pointed out that the court completely made a judgment in favor of the defendants by ignoring any of the concrete evidence.
 

View More Articles

16/07/2025
15:13 Imrali Delegation statement after meeting with Minister of Justice
12:57 Holloway: I am deeply honored to join voices supporting peace process
10:22 Saw his brother the historic ceremony: We want to see him among us
10:07 Partido Obrero supports 'I want to visit Ocalan' campaign
10:00 Witnessed the historic ceremony: Kurds should trust themselves, not the state
15/07/2025
16:57 Urgent demands from TTB for the process
15:10 Suwayda statement from Damascus: Ceasefire declared
15:03 Druze Spiritual Leader: The statement made in our name does not reflect our will
14:43 Damascus forces enter Suwayda: Curfew declared
14:38 Nagehan Avcil from OHD: Recognition of the ‘Right to Hope’ will contribute to the peace process
13:05 Newala Qesaba faces threat of concrete development
11:09 Lawyer following ceremony: Legal reforms must be implemented swiftly
10:04 Peace process is an opportunity to end attacks on nature say ecologists
09:26 Tells PJAK meeting: Freedom is only possible through national unity
09:13 Margaret Owen: No real peace process can until Öcalan is free
08:14 'Democratic Society Meetings' continue
14/07/2025
18:01 14 July resistance fighters commemorated in many cities
17:48 DEM Party Imrali Delegation to meet Minister of Justice
17:00 DEM Party İmralı Delegation's statement on 'meeting note'
15:48 Ahmet Özer released from 'urban concencus' case
15:25 Request of arrest to 3 people beaten for listening to Kurdish song
15:22 Clashes in Suwayda: 37 killed
13:23 High-level meeting between KDP and PUK
11:40 DBP, DEVA, SAADET: Commission and legal process should not be delayed
11:02 Palestine Action banned in the UK: An unjust legislation
10:51 Wan residents to state: We expect official confirmation, not just words
09:00 İmralı delegation's meeting date with political parties announced
08:49 'Democratic Society' meetings continue
08:33 CHP-affiliated Şile Municipality Mayor arrested
13/07/2025
22:13 Statement from DAANES on talks with the Damascus administration
15:58 The duty to build peace lies with all of us says DEM Party Group Deputy Chair
14:03 25 thousand people informed about the ‘Peace and Democratic Society Process’
12:43 People of Amed: We want freedom and equality
11:55 Two of her children joined the PKK: We all have a great burden on our shoulders
11:29 Mother sees her daughter at ceremony after 12 years: We want peace
10:52 IHD Co-chair who followed ceremony: The state has no more excuse
10:33 Women figth for national unity: Goal is national congress
10:03 DEM Party MPs: Parliament should play an active role in solution
09:47 Footage of forest destruction in Besta and Biliga
09:17 Rights defenders received weapons inventory to prepare report
12/07/2025
12:08 Preparoty footage of the historical ceremony
09:55 Weapons destroyed, a historic step towards peace
09:38 95 years have passed since the Zilan Massacre
09:25 People await regulation in Parliament
11/07/2025
20:17 Davutoglu: What we must do now is leading the new era
20:12 I hope this step will bring good results says Erdogan
20:09 Bese Hozat: We took this step with a clear decision
17:07 Echo of historic ceremony in Amed: Demand constitutional guarantees for those who lay down arms
16:51 CHP Chair Ozel: Process must be managed in Parliament with swift and decisive steps
16:27 Names of participants in historical ceremony of PKK